Banner Advertising: What Every Business Needs to Know

Banner advertising is no longer the obvious first move it was a few years ago, and businesses weighing whether to spend money on it deserve a straight answer instead of a sales pitch from an ad network. Here’s how to think it through.

What banner advertising is now

The standard ad sizes most sites use, the 468x60 leaderboard, the 120x60 button, the 88x31 micro-button, were set by the Internet Advertising Bureau back in 1996 and have stayed largely unchanged since. What has changed is performance. Click-through rates that ran above 2% in the format’s early days have fallen under 1% almost everywhere, and continue drifting lower as users grow accustomed to ignoring anything that looks like an ad.

That doesn’t make banners worthless. It makes them a different tool than they were sold as originally, less a direct-response engine and more a reach and awareness vehicle, and businesses need to decide which of those two jobs they need done.

The question to ask first: what are you buying it for?

If the goal is an immediate click that turns into a sale, banner advertising is now competing with newer options like keyword bidding through GoTo.com, which routes spend toward people already searching for what you sell rather than people who happen to be browsing a page. Direct-response advertisers are increasingly finding better returns there.

If the goal is putting your name in front of a specific audience repeatedly, so that when they are ready to buy, they recognize you, banner advertising still does that job reasonably well, especially on sites your customers already trust and read regularly.

What decides whether it’s worth the spend

• Audience match. A banner on a site your customers already visit for other reasons will outperform the same banner on a higher-traffic site with a mismatched audience, regardless of the price difference.
• Creative quality. Static banners with a clear, single message consistently outperform cluttered ones trying to say three things at once.
• Landing page discipline. A click that lands on a general homepage loses most of its value. A click that lands on a page matching the ad’s specific offer keeps far more of it.
• What you’re measuring. If click-through rate is the only number you’re tracking, you’re missing the point. Track what happens after the click, because a lower CTR that converts well can outperform a flashy one that doesn’t.

Who should still buy banner ads

Businesses with a genuine brand or reach objective, and the budget to buy placement on sites where their audience already spends time, still get real value from banner advertising. It remains one of the only ways to guarantee visibility to a specific audience at a known volume, something pay-per-click’s auction model doesn’t promise.

Who should look elsewhere first

Businesses with a tight budget and a direct-response goal, a specific product they need to sell this month, are increasingly better served starting with keyword-based advertising, where spend concentrates on people already looking for what’s on offer, and every dollar is easier to trace back to a result.

The honest bottom line

Banner advertising hasn’t stopped working. It has become a more specialized tool than it was treated as in 1997 and 1998, useful for specific goals rather than a default first step. Know which job you’re hiring it to do before you spend the budget.

---

Browse more Paid Advertising coverage, or see everything from 2000.