Mastering Lead Nurturing: A Marketer's Playbook

Tactics like scoring and behavioral triggers only work inside a program that’s organized. This is the operating structure behind lead nurturing programs that were performing well by late 2012, laid out as the phases a marketing operations team would run through.

Phase 1: define your personas before you write anything

Every nurture program starts with a small number of buyer personas, typically two to four, each describing a real role: what that person is responsible for, what problem brings them to your site and what would make them trust a vendor. Skipping this and writing generic content “for everyone” is the single most common reason nurture programs underperform. You can’t write relevant email to a persona you haven’t defined.

Phase 2: map existing content to funnel stage

Before creating new content, inventory what you already have and tag each piece by which persona it serves and which funnel stage it fits: awareness, consideration or decision. Most companies discover they have plenty of top-of-funnel content and almost nothing for the consideration stage, where prospects are comparing options and need something more specific than an introductory guide.

Phase 3: build the scoring model that drives the whole program

Lead nurturing without scoring is just a content calendar. Build a model that weighs fit against engagement, and use it to answer two questions for every contact: are they the right kind of prospect, and are they showing real interest right now. The score is what lets the program run itself, moving contacts between tracks and flagging the ones ready for a sales conversation without a person manually reviewing every record.

Phase 4: build the workflows, starting with your highest-value segment

Rather than building nurture tracks for every persona simultaneously, start with the segment that represents your best combination of volume and deal value. Build that track fully, including the branching logic for what happens when someone clicks versus ignores an email, launch it and use what you learn to build the next track faster.

Phase 5: set the sales handoff cadence in writing

Define exactly what happens when a lead crosses your scoring threshold: who gets notified, how fast they have to respond and what gets logged if they don’t. Programs that leave this informal watch qualified leads sit untouched in a sales queue, which quietly destroys the ROI of everything built in the earlier phases.

Phase 6: review and prune every quarter

Content ages, personas shift and workflows that made sense six months ago start producing worse results as your audience changes. Set a recurring quarterly review: which emails have the best and worst engagement, which workflows are producing MQLs that sales wants and what needs to be retired. Treat the program as something you tend continuously, not something you build once and leave running.

Run these six phases in order and lead nurturing stops being a single campaign you launched once. It becomes infrastructure: a system that keeps producing qualified pipeline whether or not anyone remembers to check on it that week.

---

Keep exploring: browse more Email Marketing guides, see everything we published in 2012 or check out the Digital Business Marketing Awards.